RSS Feed Random Comic Add To Favorites Survivor Fan Characters is proudly hosted by Smack Jeeves Webcomic Hosting.

SFC17 Day 3 Tribal Council

March 13th, 2018, 9:48 pm

Average Rating: 5.00
<< First < Previous Next > Most Recent >>

Author's Comments:

Reply SWSU-Master, March 13th, 2018, 10:00 pm

And so Amadeus leaves the game and- Wait.... He played an Idol and took out Charity? Oh right I almost forgot.

When I was doing this season's planning I knew from the very start that I wanted to do in creating a first boot that would catch pretty much everyone off guard, and to do that, I needed three simple things. 1.) An obnoxious player to take the target of being the first boot in any other season. 2.) A good decoy boot in case that person had the Idol. 3.) Enough False Story Threads with the first boot to make you all think that she was going to last a while, and possibly even win. I even went as far as to bringing up a super power she had that did not get much usage in the overall story. And considering how few people even considered Charity as an option. I'd say that mission was successful.

With Charity herself, I wanted someone who would fit into the MORP/CPP Winner mold right off the bat, but at the same time, add enough small little annoyances that wouldnt affect her in the story, but would slightly annoy the readers. (Like the Aroma Power, and the Ability to control how people felt and think would have been a SUPREMELY Overpowered ability later into the game, moreso than the EX-Machina.) But for the reason Charity left, if it wasn't clear. 1.) She was the Sane voice of reason for the others, and was able to unite everyone against Amadeus. 2.) With Her gone, Amadeus gave himself insurance. Since if he gets voted out, a team of Josh/Raiza/Tony would not go very far at all. Without Charity the team becomes dependant on Amadeus. And as Charity said in yesterdays page "As long as you have me, Amadeus is Redundant" Well... Now they no longer have her. And Tony is one pissed off dog.

Reply Advertisement, May 26th, 2019, 1:57 pm

User's Comments:

Reply Tailslover13, March 13th, 2018, 10:03 pm

WOW. I WANTED that to be the outcome, but I didn't think it'd actually happen. I mean, again, Charity was my least favorite on this tribe, and typically her type always ends up going far or being boring, but...what a shocking first elimination. I really didn't think that would happen. I had my suspicions that Amadeus would find and use an idol, but I didn't think he'd go for Charity. I'm so thankful he did, though. Now this tribe can keep being fun. You have two assholes (Tony, Amadeus), a lovable crazy girl (Raiza), and the likable straight man kitty (Josh). I love this tribe now that Charity is gone. Sorry, but for me, Charity sucked. She tried to talk a big game and be nice, but she was honestly a bitch; her comments about Josh and the way she went out here proves that she was. And, her power could've really become unfair going forward, so this was a great outcome. Also...if I'm not mistaken...this is the first time EVER that an idol has been played successfully on the very first tribal council, right? In SFC OR Survivor! So that's cool. Overall, a very great first episode, SWSU. I'm impressed. You made the right decision in getting rid of Charity, the cast as a whole is colorful, fun, and interesting, the location is great, the sprites and designs are incredible, the first two challenges mixed Pokemon elements with Survivor elements and they worked like a charm, and I can't wait to see what's next!

1. Josh (Perfection)
2. Raiza (Perfection)
3. Quickscope (Outstanding)
4. CutieCat (Amazing)
5. Derrick (Amazing)
6. Ollie (Amazing)
7. Jeannie (Amazing)
8. Amadeus (Great)
9. Lester (Great)
10. Jahira (Great)
11. Tony (Great)
12. Parmesan (Good)
13. Jenny (Good)
14. Joy (Neutral)
15. Mele (Neutral)
16. Nezumi (Neutral)
17. Naomi (Neutral)
18. Charity (Dislike) [OUT]
19. Derek (Dislike)
20. Kade (Hate)

1. Perfection - Best of the best.
2. Outstanding - Really enjoyable.
3. Amazing - A lot of fun.
4. Great - Pretty solid.
5. Good - Not bad.
6. Neutral - Some good, some bad, but mixed.
7. Dislike - Not all that enjoyable.
8. Hate - Really unlikable and awful.
9. Loathe - Worst of the worst.

Reply SWSU-Master, March 13th, 2018, 10:37 pm

@Tailslover13: Wow I'm surprised to see Josh that high up with you honestly.

Reply Tailslover13, March 13th, 2018, 10:39 pm

@SWSU-Master: I like Pokemon, especially ones that are nice, unlike Lester The Unlikely and Lea (even though I still have Lester The Unlikely fairly high anyway). And Meowth is my favorite Pokemon. Plus, with all the idiocy surrounding him, him being the exasperated straight man is charming. It just makes him a really fun character so far.

Reply Guest, March 14th, 2018, 1:05 am

@Tailslover13: He's your character lmao, thats why you like him so much. Your name is Josh and your pic is a meowth. Why are you pretending he isn't?

Reply Guest, March 14th, 2018, 11:12 pm

@Tailslover13: yeah I’m sorry but if you’re gonna act like you did from season 11, I’m gonna be pissed.

Reply GaryHawkinsLandscaper, March 14th, 2018, 11:27 pm

@Tailslover13: To the two above, we will not be having another Season 11 incident. So let the hell go.

Reply Guest (Guest), March 15th, 2018, 5:46 am

@GaryHawkinsLandscaper: you poor fool. You're in for a sad surprise.

Reply ChronoAlone, March 13th, 2018, 10:07 pm

Called it bitches! Suck my ass!


Anyway, I knew Amadeus wouldn't leave this soon. It just seemed way too obvious. I'm conflicted about how I was right, though. Having to deal with Captain Shortbus for a little while longer is going to get really annoying.

Reply SWSU-Master, March 13th, 2018, 10:38 pm

@ChronoAlone: Captain Shortbus. I like that XD

Reply Misterjakester (Guest), March 13th, 2018, 10:08 pm

Not my first pick to go, but I'm not exactly heartbroken. This is similar to Beth vote of SFC6, with the seemingly upcoming powerplayer being taken out surprisingly early. I just hope Ama doesn't last long afterwords, but with his OP pikmin, who knows

Reply SWSU-Master, March 13th, 2018, 10:38 pm

@Misterjakester : Well... I know :D

Reply DrMarble, March 13th, 2018, 10:09 pm

I should have seen this coming, SWSU you son of a bitch.

We are probably going to have to put up with Amadeus for awhile now unfortunately, but he better back up his claims, because Fini is quickly becoming a sinking ship.

Reply SWSU-Master, March 13th, 2018, 10:40 pm

@DrMarble: First Bonnie now this. Ya'll need to be more suspicious of me and early votes.

Reply Friend of Fennecs, March 13th, 2018, 10:10 pm

Yikes. The colours at Tribal Council hurt my eyes.

And so Charity is gone. Probably the member of the tribe I was most neutral on, so not a huge loss - better her than Josh or Raiza. Still, if Amadeus is here to stay, I hope he cleans up his act a bit; I really don't want him to become another Enter.

Reply SWSU-Master, March 13th, 2018, 10:41 pm

@Friend of Fennecs: Bright neon colors not your thing?

Reply Friend of Fennecs, March 14th, 2018, 1:20 am

@SWSU-Master: It's more a matter of how they're used. The cyan and magenta are both very striking, but they clash when they're right next to each other like this. Having a colour between them (like black, white, or a nice blue) would help smooth over the transition while letting them be as vivid as ever.

Reply Blastoise_FTW, March 13th, 2018, 10:11 pm


You got me, I'll tell you that much. I saw an Amadeus idol play but not a Charity boot.. About Charity herself... I won't remember her 5 days from now.

Ugh, this means Amadeus will be a douche all season long, doesn't it?

Tony about to go on a rampage?

Reply SWSU-Master, March 13th, 2018, 10:42 pm

@Blastoise_FTW: At least until he is unable to come up with an Idol.

Reply Smasher 101, March 13th, 2018, 10:14 pm

well, that happened! I thought Charity was 100% going to go far but Im satsified with being wrong because she was actually my least favorite of this tribe anyway. I wont miss her

Reply SWSU-Master, March 13th, 2018, 10:48 pm

@Smasher 101: YAY! You fell right into my trap!

Reply spinfur, March 13th, 2018, 10:16 pm

Well I'm glad Charity got the boot and not Tony since I really enjoy Tony. I had a sneaking suspicion AmaAsshole had an idol and turns out I was right. I'm glad Charity left tbh because Tails is right since her type usually does make it far. So far this tribe is my fave since i like everyone on it except AmaAsshole, but like you have to have a villain that everyone loves to hate because of how douchey they are. Great first episode can't wait to see more.

Reply GaryHawkinsLandscaper, March 13th, 2018, 10:17 pm

M-M-M-Myyyyyy Aroma It’s obviously going to look like I’m making things up after what I posted yesterday, but I did have a little bit of doubt that Amadeus wouldn’t go home. Not as much as some of the others here, but it was there. And yeah, I was pretty sure that Charity would be the next option because aside from the power she may or may not be exaggerating, she seemed like a pawn in the grand scheme of things. I just wish we got a little more out of her.


Master Troll SWSU is back, ladies and gentlemen. This is going to be one wild ride.


And what we’re doing next here is my official ranking of the castaways, replacing my original power rankings segment because... well, because I wasn’t very good with those. I’m still keeping it tribe-centered for now, and I’m only basing these on how much I enjoy them *at the moment*. So don’t freak out if your favorite character is low on the list; they might have the potential to win me over later on.

1. Quickscope
2. Derrick H.
3. Mele
4. Jenny
5. Derek L.

1. Raiza
2. Tony
3. Josh
4. Charity
5. Amadeus

1. CutieCat
2. Parmesan
3. Jahira
4. Nezumi
5. Ollie

1. Jeanie
2. Lester
3. Kade
4. Joy
5. Naomi

Reply SWSU-Master, March 13th, 2018, 10:48 pm

@GaryHawkinsLandscaper: Especially with 4 Tribes, Power Rankings are... tricky to say the least.

Reply RedBeryl, March 13th, 2018, 10:17 pm

Aroo? That part kills me~

Also, Amadeus is smarter than a lot of people give him credit for.

Lastly, SO MUCH POKEMON STUFF. The Master Ball Urn, the Max Revive Idol, the Poke Ball snuff-torch combo~ This is really cool.

Reply SWSU-Master, March 13th, 2018, 10:49 pm

@RedBeryl: When in Alola, gotta have Pokemon references.

Reply anime9001, March 13th, 2018, 10:20 pm

Yeeeeaaah, can't say I'm too surprised. You had it going pretty well SWSU, though I will say you laid her gloating on a bit thick in yesterday's comic. A single comment in the confessional about persuading Tony with her aroma was one thing, but she rambled about it for a TAD too long. Unless it was intentional to be foreseeable from last comic, because I will admit, until yesterday the possibility of Charity leaving didn't even come to mind. Especially with the cast preview. She had arguably one of the safest previews of the entire cast to make it far into this game. And one decoy boot? On this tribe sure, but There was someone on 3 tribes that felt prime for a first boot. For all intents and purposes, I'd say this was pulled off well.

And with that, I....guess we're stuck with Amadeus for a while! As much as I love Pikmin, I can't say I'm too happy with this outcome. Charity looked like she would have been an interesting character, and Amadeus can be.....a tad insuffurable. But we need characters of all kinds! And with the people remaining on this tribe, it kinda does feel like Amadeus will be leading Pikmin from here on out.

Reply SWSU-Master, March 13th, 2018, 10:51 pm

@anime9001: The gloating was like the only red flag I could raise without raising too much suspicion, But I also needed SOME hints.

Reply anime9001, March 13th, 2018, 11:07 pm

@SWSU-Master: That's fair. It would feel quite forced otherwise afterall.

Reply dat4yc, March 13th, 2018, 10:41 pm

Holy shit I wasn’t expecting that...

I’m actually pretty happy about this. As much as I dislike Amadeus, he is wayyyyyy more interesting than Charity. I was just worried Josh or Tony was gonna get voted out which would’ve been just the worst. Charity was fine, but if someone had to leave it’s pretty great that it was her.


Ollie > Quickscope > Raiza > Jeannie > Josh > Parmesan > Tony > CutieCat > Derrick > Lester > Kade > Mele > Jahira > Derek > Amadeus > Joy > Jenny > Naomi > Nezumi

Reply SWSU-Master, March 13th, 2018, 10:53 pm

@dat4yc: I know it's a personal ranking and not a wishlist. But an Ollie/Quickscope Top 2 would be hilarious to see.

Reply EJ122, March 13th, 2018, 11:11 pm

I'm not happy. I'm not mad about this development, just unhappy. At least it was Charity that took the bullet, and that we don't have to see her persuade people with her "aroma."

Amadeus clearly has too many unfair advantages - enough that it's blatant cheating, and combining that with his horrible personality, he's already one of my least favorite SFC characters.

Jahira (Like)
Jenny (Like)
Derek (Like)
Quickscope (Like)
Raiza (Like)
CeCe (Like)
Tony (Like)
Derrick (Like)
Josh (Like)
Jeannie (Like)
Kade (Neutral)
Ollie (Neutral)
Lester (Neutral)
Parmesan (Neutral)
Nezumi (Neutral)
Naomi (Neutral)
Charity (Neutral)(Eliminated)
Joy (Neutral)
Mele (Neutral)
Amadeus (Loathe)

Reply Sonofhades, March 14th, 2018, 9:25 am

@EJ122: There are already Enter comparisons being made, and that's not a good thing.

Reply SWSU-Master, March 14th, 2018, 9:40 pm

@EJ122: That's quite the accomplishment after Episode 1

Reply MechanicalMind, March 14th, 2018, 12:55 am

That Tribal Council was very interesting indeed. Who would have thought that Amadeus had his sights on Charity when he came to the votes? But what would this mean for Fini? I'll know that Tony is going to make a plan of revenge to serve for Amadeus. Amadeus might want to keep finding the idols with his pikmin, unless he got more than the Max-Revive hidden immunity idol on his last treasure hunt. Raiza is probably going to do something crazy and kill his pikmin by burning them up and dousing them with water balloons. I don't know what Josh will do but I hope he can survive to the swap, so that he could start a good game, without a confrontation.

Speaking of Amadeus, I can't help but wonder. Has he managed to collect more than one idol on his last idol treasure-hunt? Because that could be a possibility... wait is there only one idol at each camp?

Reply SWSU-Master, March 14th, 2018, 9:43 pm

@MechanicalMind: Thankfully he only has one Max Revive at a time, so he's not THAT broken.

Reply SkySurfer, March 14th, 2018, 1:22 am

Misson accomplished, SWSU. Since there were some missed opportunities in past seasons it's refreshing SFC17 starts with a surprise boot just from the beginning.

Before today's comic I was convinced that Amadeus' arrogance would make him blind enough to leave in a 4-1 vote but it's interesting he was still smarter than that. I wonder if it was pure coincidence he targeted Charity or if he was the only one to understand her manipulation ability. I guess we will have to bear him for a while now.

As for Charity: Too bad but better her than one of the others. Her scent ability would have been annoying later and her alliance members were more interesting from the beginning. With her departure Fini will stay chaotic until a tribe swap.

Reply SWSU-Master, March 14th, 2018, 9:43 pm

@SkySurfer: For the Dynamics to improve, Charity was def the best option.

Reply Guest, March 14th, 2018, 3:27 am

I love how everyone hated Enter so bad that SWSU decided "Hey, I can do much worse!"

Reply SWSU-Master, March 14th, 2018, 9:44 pm

@Guest: Is he that much worse?

Reply SR17 (Guest), March 14th, 2018, 8:50 am


That was a damn smart move on Deus's part - still, I have to wonder if her went out of his way to talk down everybody before the vote.

Also. Are Pikmin allow- oh wait they probably came with the suit.

Okay, first order of business - getting rid of that damn suit.

Reply SWSU-Master, March 14th, 2018, 9:44 pm

@SR17: THats a very smart idea tbh

Reply Sonofhades, March 14th, 2018, 9:25 am

Called it. Right down to the comparisons with Enter. Charity wasn't necessarily a bad character, but she was certainly a boring one. The fly-under-the-radar power player thing doesn't work out well on TV and it doesn't work out well here. I'm not exactly happy that Amadeus is still here, but I'm going to be happy when people finally take his tiny ass out. This is going to make for some very fun storylines.

Reply SWSU-Master, March 14th, 2018, 9:45 pm

@Sonofhades: At least it was Charity that left and not someone with more potential.

Reply NickIt'sTheName, March 14th, 2018, 12:29 pm

Well, i was wrong.

Ranking order for each tribe. (You will have to wait till merge to know my favorite <3(Except for those that get eliminated)(The ranking can and may change)
First place


Second favorite

Ollie (please, make it to the jury lol)

Third place


18. Charity

Dead last

Amadeus (Die)

Is complicate, but i'm like that.

Reply SWSU-Master, March 14th, 2018, 9:45 pm

@NickIt'sTheName: I would hope it would change as the season progresses :P

Reply SR17 (Guest), March 14th, 2018, 12:49 pm

My current character ratings: Raiza : 1 / 7
Amadeus : -5 / 6
Tony : -1 / 7
Josh : 1 / 7
Charity : 0 / 7

Jeannie : 3 / 6
Kade : 0 / 6
Joy : 0 / 5
Naomi : 0 / 5
Lester : -3 / 6

Mele : 0 / 5
Quickscope : 1 / 5
Derek : 1 / 5
Derrick : 3 / 5
Jenny : 2 / 5

Parmesean : 0 / 6
CeCe : 3 / 6
Jahira : 2 / 6
Nezumi : 0 / 6
Ollie : -1 / 5

Scoring on a per-comic basis. Everybody starts at 0. A character does something I like, +1. Something I dislike, -1. Each person can only be rated once per comic. Only characters who appeared in the current comic can be ranked.

(Their current score / Their current Maximum Score) (Current minimum score is just maximum*-1)

Reply SWSU-Master, March 14th, 2018, 9:46 pm

@SR17: Amadeus, Lester, Tony and Ollie are rocking those negative scores!

Reply vanilladream, March 14th, 2018, 5:14 pm

I thought of something witty to say about this earlier but forgot what I was gonna say. In any case, I am pretty surprised to see Charity leave so early, so props on that. Just glad it wasn't Tony, though, honestly. He has been very entertaining so far.

Reply SWSU-Master, March 14th, 2018, 9:46 pm

@vanilladream: And with Charity gone, Tony is now literally unleashed.

Reply qazox, March 15th, 2018, 9:02 am

Gotta admit did not see that coming.

Reply Red Rain (Guest), April 4th, 2018, 7:15 pm

Okay, I did not expect Charity to be the first boot. I thought Josh would be leaving instead. That confirms Amadeus will be sticking around for a while, using his Pikmin to find an idol was cheap, but effective at the same time. What a way to kick off the first three days.

Reply Cauldron (Guest), January 4th, 2019, 3:40 pm

Yeah, you fooled me...

Derrick obviously has the strongest winner's edit right now, but he feels WAY too obvious.

I am excited to read the comment section when/if Josh is voted out...

Post A Comment