RSS Feed Random Comic Add To Favorites Survivor Fan Characters is proudly hosted by Smack Jeeves Webcomic Hosting.

SFC8 Finale

September 4th, 2011, 10:45 pm

Average Rating: 5.00
<< First < Previous Next > Most Recent >>

Author's Comments:

Reply SWSU-Master, September 4th, 2011, 10:58 pm

And so Melanie ends up winning, and Heinz outlasts Matt kinda... Thus another seasons wraps up, and No Redemption Island in SFC9. 10 of my characters, 10 applicant characters.

Also, I am out of town, and internet is very.... bad right now. So if you want me to answer anything about the season, just ask it here, and when I get the time to, I'll address it.

Reply Advertisement, May 22nd, 2019, 11:40 pm

User's Comments:

Reply AkumaTh, September 4th, 2011, 11:01 pm

And Mel won the whole thing. It was definitely hers to win.

So I take it you have the 10 picked for next season?

Reply SkylerJ, September 4th, 2011, 11:04 pm

While I will admit this season probably had one of my least favourite winners I have to admit I love most of the cast this time around. Overall not my favourite season but it wasn't horrible. Can't wait for the next season! Thanks for the comic as always SWSU!

Reply Vilecheese, September 4th, 2011, 11:07 pm

Lol, it wasn't even close.

As much a Melanie did end up being Suish, she did still deserve this win. So good job to her, and here's hoping SFC9 will be awesome!

Reply mydoctor93, September 4th, 2011, 11:11 pm

@Vilecheese Congrats on edgic victory! lol

Reply Weaver Tyialo, September 4th, 2011, 11:12 pm

Another interesting season. Not gonna lie, not my favorite season, but still a good season none-the-less. I hope I return from my internet loss that I've been warned about before the next season comes out.

Reply QJD (Guest), September 4th, 2011, 11:12 pm

What a lackluster season.

Reply Sine Diego, September 4th, 2011, 11:15 pm

I admittedly would've preferred Heinz to take the win, but I'm satisfied enough that Matt hasn't won either.

Well played, Melanie. Well played.

Reply bennyboy, September 4th, 2011, 11:24 pm

The season wasn't one of the best (it was better than 5 at least), but I will admit Melanie's among my favourite winners. Negative female winners ftw!

And I loled so hard at Matt getting 0 votes. I still can't believe he threw the freebie vote!

Reply Vilecheese, September 4th, 2011, 11:24 pm

@mydoctor93: Thanks! lol

Reply Reynolds Zephyr, September 4th, 2011, 11:27 pm

To quote MissingParticle from the last page... Did it ever get explained why Hannah names herself Oehda in SFC? Did Hannah hate her real name?

Reply Samurai pizza hedgehog, September 4th, 2011, 11:31 pm

YES!! YES!!! WOOOOOOOOOOOOOT YEAH!

Reply Feniks, September 4th, 2011, 11:47 pm

Lol'ed at the Redemption Island part, overall... the season was good, and had some great characters but the winner is sadly bleak...

Reply Matt Thorndark, September 4th, 2011, 11:52 pm

Hey, SWSU, if at all possible, can Matt take Melanie's place in the next season's cast releases and call himself the real winner of this season, only to be beaten up by her before he could really do anything in them?

Reply PhantomJames, September 4th, 2011, 11:57 pm

Aw, I was wrong.

And now I wait for season 9 where it will hopefully have wonderful edible goodness.

Reply Ryo the Hedgehog (Guest), September 5th, 2011, 12:09 am

Let's see... Matt screwed up his freebie, Heinz' alliance still backed him up despite the lie, and Melanie won by a landside. I'm going to say that it's not bad in a good season's performence and plot. Great season man. Great season.

Reply cRaZyKiD (Guest), September 5th, 2011, 12:19 am

SFC 8 RANKINGS! [redacted]

Reply SkySurfer (Guest), September 5th, 2011, 12:31 am

And so Melanie wins the season just as it had to be predicted. In the end I would have prefered Heinz but Melanie actually won the game like Phil could have won it last season.

This wasn't my favorite season but it wasn't a bad one either.
We saw many nice survivors with their own unique style. Matt however was a poor excuse for a villian, Wrecker had so much more style and so we can be more thankful for characters like Iraenus, Jackie and Xero who you could hate on one side but give a thumbs up on the other.

Thank god there was no idol flood in this season, there were some nice twists with the Midway Island but most TribalCouncils were really predictable. It wasn't just once I was expecting a twist where there was none, this even goes for the final. We knew weeks before that Heinz had almost no chance to win because of the secret. Moments like the Malik bar and other funny conversations made up a bit for the lack of surprises.

Well after so many seasons, it becomes harder to have new ideas and character profiles so it's nice you're still working so hard, SWSU. Looking forward to your next season, any idea how long it might take?

Reply Tinyhammer (Guest), September 5th, 2011, 5:01 am

Well, Melanie wins it all... You know, she is okay and she DID deserved it but she was so much of a Sue with things ALWAYS going her way. If she had problems, I would better be okay with her win but still... Oh well... Congrats, anyway.

Reply Bad Asp, September 5th, 2011, 6:25 am

She's one of my favorite SFC winners of all time! I think she deserved that win!

You see, Penny? THAT is how to be a successful female villain!

Of course, I updated my SFC8 chart to include the latest information! Check it out at http://bad-asp.deviantart.com/art/SFC8-progress-chart-206168586 !

(Okay, I like shamelessly plugging my pictures. So?)

Reply mtugby (Guest), September 5th, 2011, 9:05 am

So Melanie wins, she's my least favourite winner sadly, but a well deserved win imo.

My rankings:

16. Malik (6th Place)
The reason he's last is that he just did nothing for me. I have no idea why he lasted this long, and his antics weren't funny imo. Him and Jackie should have switched places imo for the OTTN character that got far.

15. Matt (2nd Runner-Up)
Matt really got on my nerves for the whole season with his arrogance, I'm glad that in the end Heinz beat him.

14. Shaniqua (16th Place)
I really don't like these sort of people at all. But looking back over it, it would have been much more interesting to see her last a bit longer.

13. Johnny (9th Place)
I didn't find him funny at all sadly. And again, I don't know why he lasted so long. I really would have preferred seeing Alice switch places with him as the OTTP character.

12. Freddie (15th Place)
Cool guy, but didn't really do much.

11. Heinz (Runner-Up)
I liked him at the start, he's just like me in real life, so I had to back him. But then when he returned, he just seemed to turn into an idiot which is why he has gone from originally 1st to 11th. If he took out Melanie, I think he could have definitely won.

10. Melanie (Winner)
My opinion on her has changed way too many times. First, I liked her, then when I seen her personality I hated her. Then I liked her again when she dropped it. And then finally at the merge, I really really didn't like her for her arrogance and how obvious it was that she was the winner.

9. Iraenus (4th Place)
For the whole season, I pretty much hated him. He was just really annoying, but towards the end I started to like him as he was the underdog and he should have been in the final really if not for Heinz's stupidity.

8. Oehda (8th Place)
I never really liked Oehda much, but she was a very interesting character.

7. Geena (5th Place)
I don't really know why Geena lasted this long. She felt like the likeable pre merge character to me. I don't have much to say about her, I liked her towards the end, but I don't think she should have made it this far.

6. Kiara (7th Place)
I liked Kiara, she was the positive character who I like to root for. But I don't know, I just don't really feel like in the end I liked her all that much. On the plus side, her jury character, was hot.

5. Xero (10th Place)
Unlike others, I did actually like Xero. He was just trying to play the game really, and his jury character was a lot more positive too.

4. Penny (13th Place)
I really liked Penny, she was just the fail villain, and she was really funny to watch. Her boot is probably one of my all time favourites.

3. Jackie (11th Place)
I don't know if I like Jackie or not, but he was definitely one of the most interesting characters of the season, and I really think he should have made the merge.

2. Alice (14th Place)
Ah I liked Alice. She was a nice girl, who had a lot more potential but was sadly voted out over Malik who should have really went at that point. She really should have lasted a bit longer, and developed more.

1. Emilee (12th Place)
And Emilee is my favourite of the season. I liked her from the go, and all the way through to her boot. She's just a nice down to earth girl, who I found really rootable. It's a shame that she didn't last long.

Reply Manablitz (Guest), September 8th, 2011, 9:11 pm

I'm glad Melanie won. Are you gonna post finale notes?

Reply qazox, October 7th, 2011, 12:51 am

I wanna know where heinz was really from and why Hannah changed he name to Oehda!!!

Reply ManaBlitz (Guest), October 13th, 2011, 10:41 pm

SFC8 Character Rankings SFC8 was hated and I don't understand why. It's honestly not that bad. It had much better gameplay then season 7 imo. And memorable characters.

16-Freddie (SSX Tricky/15th): Boring idiot dummy.

15-Alice (PokeMoN/14th): Kinda a cute throwaway character.

14-Penny (Batman/13th): She was a bit weird and she was stupid as fuck, but entertaining.

13-Shaniqua (America's Next Top Model/16th): LOL at her series and LOL at her character.

12-Kiara (Megaman/7th): ugh Heinzshipper. other then that she was okay.

11-Emilee (Buffy/12th): I liked her more then Kiara cause of her cooler alliance but she wasn't that memorable for me.

10-Johnny (Scrubs/9th): He was pretty entertaining, and his relationship with Matt reminded me of Marius and Gate, except Matt was not NEARLY as amazing.

9-Heinz (Tekken(jk)/Runner up): Heinz was kinda boring, only being carried by his rivalry with Matt and then his being manipulated by Melanie.

8-Xero (Rocko's Modern Life/10th): he was fun when he mutinied and I enjoyed his schemes and antics.

7-Matt (Mario Sports/3rd): Part of what made Matt a fun character was that he was so easy to root against. He was similar to Baxter except he had all the arrogance without the backstabbing skills.

6-Jackie (Darkwing Duck/11th): Jackie was fun with his rivalry against Oehda and he was entertaining for sure.

5-Geena (Ranma 1/2/5th): geena was a little boring but she was likeable and was a great duo with Iraenus.

4-Melanie (Darkstalkers/WINNER): Melanie was a great player and winner imo, and I thought she was awesome.

3-Iraenus (Grim Adventures/4th): Iraenus was endlessly entertaining and I loved his OTT-ness. Definitely memorable and outrageous.

2-Malik (Sonic The Hedgehog): This is probably a little WTF but Mailk was great. Very entertaining, and imo very likable. He is definitely one of the best crazies (maybe almost as good as Kala.... MAYBE)

1-Oehda/Hannah (Friends/8th): I rooted for her the whole time she was on. She was great. Definitely the highlight of the season. She had the best alliance and the best rivalry imo.

Top 5 Players:
#5: Matt?
#4: Oehda
#3: Iraenus
#2: Geena
#1: Melanie

Reply Austin0017, May 26th, 2012, 2:59 pm

OMG YES! I luv Melanie so much
she was my fave for this season and I'm glad she won, totally deserved
I think she's tied with Norman for my favorite SFC every!

Reply A Random Person (Guest), July 11th, 2012, 12:32 pm

SFC 8 Rankings [redacted]

Reply I<3REALITY (Guest), January 20th, 2013, 11:29 pm

YAY!i!i!i!i! SMART AND PRETTY! GO MELANIE!

Reply sonofhades (Guest), September 7th, 2013, 1:48 pm

After rereading with more insight into Survivor than ever, I can see why the fanbase hates the season so much. Started out great, but it fell apart at the final vote. I have nothing wrong with a negative winner, but this season may as well have been named "Survivor Fan Characters 8: Just Give Melanie the Million."

Reply Cauldron (Guest), May 26th, 2018, 3:57 pm

I liked this season for the most part. The characters were really hit or miss for me, but the good characters really helped the season.

Cast rankings:

16th- Heinz- When I first started this season, I was expecting him to be similar to Barney and Marius, both of whom were my favorites on their seasons. He gave me a similar vibe, so I instantly made him my top edgic contender and he remained in that spot until he was voted out.. and then he regained the spot when he was voted back in... and then he finally lost it to Melanie in the second to last episode. He was pretty average for me before the outcast twist, but he became boring and repetitive after he came back. Happy to see him lose.

15th- Kiara- Mindless follower of Heinz. Snore.

14th- Freddie- Popper wannabe

13th- Shaniqua- lol

12th- Xero- his storyline revolved around being dumb and having a weakness for women..

11th- Alice- too OTT to be a good character; definitely the worst of the "mean girls" alliance.

10th- Malik- I honestly probably skimmed over a lot of his dialogue.. it was painful to read. I guess he was entertaining at times, but he fell flat for me.

9th- Johnny- annoying and mindless, but he had his moments

8th- Geena- she was a constant MOR presence, but she never developed in the way I'd expect a finalist to develop. She definitely contributed to the season, though.

7th- Emilee- She was very MOR, and I wish we got more development from her. I enjoyed her while she lasted.

6th- Penny- she was a really solid premerger. I wish she lasted longer. I liked her storyline of wanting to be the villain, and then she has the most ridiculous exit the comic has seen.

5th- Iraenus- he was annoying and OTT at times, bur he definitely did his part in driving the story forward, and he was a contender until the end.

4th- Jackie- Solid OTTN premerge villain. I'm glad he went out when he did, because he was getting repetitive and he was against Oehda, but he was a great addition to the season.

3rd- Melanie- I was expecting a male to win this season, so it took me a while to consider her as a winner. Ultimately, I'm definitely glad she won over Heinz. I definitely think I liked Ellise, Montana, Barney, and Marius better than her, but she is definitely above Sky for me and probably Ker too.

2nd- Matt- I loved him as a "villain." He thought he was going to be the supervillain mastermind of the season, but he really just turned into a big joke by the end. He's kinda like Penny, except he succeeded at being a villain until the merge..

1st- Oehda- Obviously. I supported her from the start, and I really wish she made it farther than 8th place. I loved her initial storyline of the mutiny / becoming the leader, and she absolutely dominated the story for the first three episodes. She was a great villain, and I hope she comes back some day.. Possibly my all time favorite SFC character (so far... I've only read up to this season).

Post A Comment